Sunday, 26 June 2016

Glimmers of Hope for Brisbane Despite Richmond Defeat

Although the 2016 AFL season has been a dismal one for Brisbane, there are some positive signs for the future thanks to some of the youngsters that are emerging.

The Lions lost to Richmond by 42 points on Saturday and collectively they played uninspiring footy but there were some young players who showed that they deserve to be in the senior squad.

If there was one youngster that appealed to me more than the others, it was key forward Eric Hipwood.

He scored 3.2 from just seven disposals in only his second game of AFL football, which is quite impressive when great forwards like Wayne Carey and Jonathan Brown had to wait for their sixth and seventh games respectively to score their first senior goal.

His fellow key forward Josh Schache has played 13 games this season and against Richmond he had just eight touches but he scored a goal and set-up three others.

Both Hipwood and Schache were selected by Brisbane in the 2015 AFL draft and Lions coach Justin Leppitsch said after the game against the Tigers that they would be Brisbane’s key forwards of the future.

Currently it seems that Brisbane lacks a clear gameplan but Leppitsch should encourage the rest of the Lions team to supply the duo with as much footy as possible.

Although they are both slender in build and under 20 years old, they need regular playing time and the midfielders need to believe that Schache and Hipwood are two reliable targets in the forward 50.

In midfield the experienced players are not making a huge impact on games but youngsters like Rhys Mathieson and Jarrad Jansen displayed moments of quality.

Mathieson played his third game of AFL footy against the Tigers and he has been criticised for ducking but he showed that he has some skills. He had 24 disposals including 14 contested ones and he had seven skill involvements.

Jansen was playing his fourth game for Brisbane and although he only had 16 disposals, 13 of them were contested. The former Geelong midfielder also had six clearances, with Tom Rockliff having more with seven.

Overall the defeat to Richmond was due to another insipid performance from Brisbane and the Lions had more room to play in the final quarter because the Tigers had slowed down.

It is important for the Lions to see these youngsters emerge though because a number of senior players have not been performing well recently so their spots need to be put under pressure. Injuries have also played a part but these kids have to make everything count and take their chances at senior level.

Brisbane is not expected to climb up the AFL ladder anytime soon but the likes of Hipwood, Schache, Mathieson, and Jansen showed offer signs of hope for the long-suffering Lions supporters.

Sunday, 22 May 2016

Brisbane coaching staff needs to be held to account

Brisbane needs to look at its coaching staff after the Lions succumbed to another defeat.

On Sunday the Lions lost to Melbourne by 63 points and although there was more effort than in the defeat against Collingwood, there were still some skill errors made and the inaccuracy in front of goal still remains.

To keep blaming the players or poor recruiting is narrow-minded in my view and certain aspects of Brisbane’s coaching need to be assessed.

If the press conference after the 78-point loss against the Magpies was anything to go by, head coach Justin Leppitsch seems to have lost faith in his own ability to coach the Lions.

This team has progressed little since 2014 and the players are inconsistent performers. Leppitsch from the outside looking in does not come across as a great strategist or a great motivator.

It is very easy to single out the senior coach and it is also easy to blame the players for a lack of ability or effort but how about the assistant coaches?

Leigh Harding and Scott Borlace are the development coaches but the results so far have shown that they have not done much to develop the players. They should be teaching the players to improve their skills and decision making.

Gary O’Donnell is the Skill Development and Training Coordinator but he has been at the club for too long. He probably is not the right person to assist Harding and Borlace.

Maybe it is time to hire someone who has been associated with successful clubs of recent seasons. What worked during the glory days doesn’t necessarily work now so O’Donnell could do with a change of atmosphere.

Mitch Hahn does not seem to be doing well as a defensive coach. Tackling, smothering, and spoiling need to be improved dramatically as well as the ability to use the ball well in defence.

Ben Hudson might be ideal as a ruck coach but coaching forwards should not be his role. He was never a prolific goalscorer so he is not the right guy to teach the players to kick accurately for goal. Brisbane needs a forward coach who can teach the players to make leads, take marks, and kick goals.

Murray Davis is the transition strategy coach but it is clear the players struggle to get the ball out of defence or midfield.

Davis should be finding ways to get the ball moving with skill and effectiveness but it has not happened. Brisbane lacks experienced players so he should realise that young players are not the type of players to dictate the play. The Lions need to be more instinctive when they play.

Danny Daly is the stoppage strategy coach but he seems to be doing a poor job. Brisbane struggles at stoppages and the Lions need to be better at winning the ball, closing down spaces, and marking opposition players. The Lions need to be quick at getting the ball out of congested areas.

Simon Black is the midfield coach but he should do more to teach the midfielders and make them follow his advice. He was one of the greats as a midfielder so he can advise the players on how to use the ball.

In addition to the assistant coaches, Brisbane reserves coach Shane Woewodin needs to be criticised for the woeful job he is doing. The Lions usually get thrashed by 100 points and some of these players have played in the senior squad.

What does Woewodin know about developing players or game plans? So far he is not producing players who can step into the senior squad and put pressure on under-performing players.

Coaches are put under the spotlight when their team is losing regularly but Leppitsch cannot have 100 per cent of the blame. The coaches around him need to improve or they need to go.

Sunday, 1 May 2016

Brisbane was So Close to Victory Against Sydney

Brisbane lost to Sydney today but the Lions can take pride in the performance that they put on show, almost coming close to victory themselves.

Although the Lions only lead for a few minutes in the first quarter, they kept on persisting and they avoided another heavy defeat like the one they got last week against the Western Bulldogs.

There some were some players that under-performed in the three-point defeat but there were others that performed well in slippery conditions at the Gabba.

The Positives

Dayne Zorko was the standout for Brisbane with 33 disposals, seven tackles and a goal. He showed great fight and stamina and he used the ball well throughout the match. Pearce Hanley was also fantastic for the Lions, collecting 25 disposals, making 12 tackles and scoring two vital goals.

Mitch Robinson gathered 28 disposals and made seven tackles and he demonstrated once again that he is one of Brisbane’s toughest midfielders. He was a hard tackler and he went in hard into the contests.

Daniel Rich is a player that gets moved around the ground from time to time and he was a solid performer today. He touched the ball 23 times, made five tackles and he kicked two goals, showing that he can be a handy goal-scorer when he is in scoring range.

Allen Christensen touched the ball 17 times but he took seven marks and scored three goals, more than any other Brisbane player. He was usually present in the contest and he was slick in tight areas. After a tough 2015, this season he has shown that he is starting to be a key contributor for the Lions.

Ben Keays made his debut and got 11 disposals but he made eight tackles and kicked 1.1. It was not an amazing start to his AFL career but it was a solid introduction nevertheless.

Although Tom Rockliff gained 32 disposals, I felt that most of the other on-ballers made more of an impact with their ball use. 

The Negatives

Arguably the biggest disappointment from this game aside from the result itself was the performance of Lewis Taylor.

In his 50th match, his impact was not positive and he touched the ball only 11 times. There were a number of occasions in which he failed to control the ball and some of these opportunities to control the ball where at times in which he could have given Brisbane the lead.

Although Josh Walker scored the final goal of the match, his performance was rather poor. When he plays in the forward 50, he struggles to make leads, he has trouble taking marks, and he doesn’t create space for his teammates.

Walker works hard when he goes into the ruck so he is probably better off being a back-up to Stefan Martin than to become a key forward. Daniel McStay also struggled in the forward line, scoring one goal and only taking three marks.

Where Do the Lions Go From Here?

A trip to South Australia is next for Brisbane, who will play Port Adelaide at the Adelaide Oval next Sunday. The Power defeated Richmond on Saturday night but Brisbane needs to display the same determination and effort that they showed against Sydney.

Dayne Beams might play his first game of the season for the Lions against Port Adelaide, which would be great for the midfield, but Justin Leppitsch needs to fix his forward line.

Josh Schache needs to return after having a week’s rest so the Lions can have an additional target in the forward 50. It is unlikely that Walker will be dropped but Leppitsch is better off bringing back Jonathan Freeman and persisting with him because Walker doesn’t look like a player capable of becoming an elite key forward.

Brisbane showed that it was tough to beat but these sort of performances need to be replicated consistently. Defeating Port Adelaide might not be an easy task for the Lions but they must prove to all the other AFL sides that they are not a bunch of easybeats.

Thursday, 14 April 2016

Brisbane Lions Must Makes Tactical Changes

Brisbane has lost its first three games of 2016 and it needs to make changes to its playing style. This “run and gun” game plan is not working for now so tweaks must be made to make it work.

The Lions are making the usual mistakes that they have been in recent years. They take too much time to think when they have the ball, their disposals by hand and foot are short, and they handball themselves into trouble.

When the player with the ball handballs to a teammate, he takes pressure off himself but the teammate who receives the footy is already under pressure. The player who receives the ball is not in space and usually there are opposition players ready to tackle him.

Brisbane’s players struggle to make smart decisions. When they dispose of the ball by going sideways and backwards, they lack purpose. It seems that they do it to maintain possession and nothing else. When the Lions play at a slow tempo or become indecisive, they invite pressure from the opposition. If they take a long time to bring the ball back into play, they allow enough time for the opposition to set themselves up.

When Brisbane has registered wins in the Leppitsch era, the Lions have usually had space to play the game or they created space for themselves when the opposition try to tighten things up.

For instance, Brisbane played fast, instinctive and direct footy when they defeated Port Adelaide and the Western Bulldogs at the Gabba in 2015. The Lions are not the type of team to chip the ball around the ground like Hawthorn and West Coast and the Western Bulldogs have shown under Luke Beveridge that youth is not an excuse. If you can organise a team and put your players into positions that suit their characteristics, they can do well.

Brisbane should play at a fast tempo because they have quick players and that speed should be use to the team’s advantage but they need space to really use it to great effect.

Goals obviously win games so the faster the Lions get the footy into the forward 50, the more chances they have to score. That requires going directly though because a team goes nowhere by kicking the ball sideways and backwards.

Since the Brisbane players have shown that they are poor at decision making, they need to be fast and instinctive so they can reduce their thinking time. Leppitsch needs to instruct his players to take the game on and make them believe that taking big risks will result in big rewards.

Handballs must be cut down drastically because the Lions create too many turnovers from them. Hawthorn and Geelong are different because the players make overlapping runs and they handball vertically or diagonally, which Brisbane struggle to do.

The focus for the Lions should be on kicking long, especially with key forwards like Josh Walker, Josh Schache and Jonathan Freeman on the list.

Even if Brisbane doesn’t kick to a contest or to a player on the lead, there must be kicks into an area of space in which a play can run into.

It is easy for people to use youth, injuries and the fixture as an excuse but the Lions need to improve tactically to make themselves more competitive.

Monday, 7 September 2015

Leppitsch must learn lessons from Brisbane's win against Bulldogs

Justin Leppitsch should have learned his lesson after Brisbane defeated the Western Bulldogs on Saturday afternoon.

The Lions won by eight points against the Dogs at the Gabba and they did it in style. After an insipid display in the first quarter, Brisbane played quickly, directly and instinctively.

Errors aplenty were made by Brisbane in the first quarter and the Western Bulldogs scored seven of their first eight goals from turnovers.

That display in the first quarter summed up the seasons of both teams. Leppitsch’s side was slow and indecisive and the disposals were going sideways and backwards. On the other hand, Luke Beveridge’s side were attacking at pace and disposing the ball with great accuracy.

From the second quarter onwards, Brisbane players were hitting their targets and they didn’t look lost and confused. They played with purpose, direction and flair. It also helped that Leppitsch actually had his players in roles that they could perform.

Justin Clarke played as a back pocket instead of a tall defender and the youngster was vital in the final quarter, making some good spoils and taking a mark near the goal-line in the dying minutes of the game.

Daniel Rich was excellent in midfield with three assists and 13 score involvements. He is a superb passer of the ball and it makes you wonder why he plays in the backline in some games. Rich’s vision is as good as any elite midfielder in the AFL.

Pearce Hanley got 35 disposals and scored two goals, including one scored with the outside of his boot in the third quarter. The Irishman is a ball magnet but he provides dash and spark when Brisbane goes forward. He too is another player that needs to be near the forward 50.

The change in game style worked to the advantage Lewis Taylor, who scored three goals and got 28 disposals. He has suffered second-year blues and has had a tendency to run in circles but on Saturday he played like the player who won last year’s NAB Rising Star award, demonstrating his pace and goal-sneak abilities.

Stefan Martin starred in the ruck with 32 disposals and 50 hit-outs and the Lions must do whatever they can to keep him. He can ruck alone and he is a fantastic player around the ground.

Brisbane played with two key forwards in Daniel McStay and Jonathan Freeman and although they only kicked three goals between them, they provided reference points in the Brisbane attack. Their presence allowed the likes of Josh Green and Jed Adcock to run free and score goals.

Both Green and Adcock scored four goals each and the former showed that he can be one of the league’s best small forwards. Adcock was playing in his final game for Brisbane but he has shown in recent matches that he can be a useful medium-sized forward.

The result may have been too little, too late and Brisbane could miss out on recruiting promising youngster Josh Schache in the draft this year but the Lions avoided the wooden spoon and played some footy that was delightful to watch.

Hopefully Leppitsch noticed that players should play in roles that suit them and the team should play with attacking intent. With this in mind, the 2016 AFL season shouldn’t be bleak for the Brisbane Lions.  

Monday, 20 July 2015

Brisbane must question the future of Justin Leppitsch

Justin Leppitsch is not the right man to take the Brisbane Lions forward and his future as the coach of the Lions needs to be questioned seriously.

He was a great player for the Lions but he looks out of his depth as a coach in the AFL. It is easy to use excuses like he hasn’t always had a full strength team to choose from or he needs better players but he hasn’t been able to work with what he has at his disposal.

The Lions play with fear and confusion. There isn’t a clear gameplan present and the team lacks purpose and direction. Worst of all, a majority of players are placed out of position or they have change roles constantly.

Brisbane has had a habit of turning the ball over by hand and foot, moving the ball sideways or backwards and taking time to make decisions.

Are the Brisbane players as poorly skilled as they are made out to be?

No. Last year some of Brisbane’s smaller midfielders were labelled “The Mosquito Fleet”, which was a nickname also given to Carlton’s midfield in the 1970s. Surely these Lions players haven’t lost their skill in the space of a year and there are other good players on the Brisbane list, not just in midfield.

Tom Rockliff and Dayne Beams are prolific ball-getters. Lewis Taylor, Pearce Hanley and Josh Green are quick and nippy players who can provide some spark. Dayne Zorko and Daniel Rich are talented midfielders who can also go forward and kick goals.

Stefan Martin is as good as any ruckman in the league when he is given the responsibility. Daniel Merrett is great spoiler of the ball, Harris Andrews and Marco Paparone are tall defenders with great mobility and Justin Clarke has shown that he is better at being a running defender than playing as an old-school key defender.

Brisbane does lack great tall forwards but if Daniel McStay could stay in the forward 50 and not drop back, he could develop better. Matthew Leuenberger lacks the courage to play on the ball but if “Leuey” modelled himself of Jarryd Roughead or past players like Simon Madden or Paul Salmon, he could be a decent forward.

So what are the issues?

This team lacks mental strength, structure, and a playing philosophy, which is different to a gameplan.

The Lions players must not be limited to playing in a role or restricted to a system. They need to have the confidence to make their own decisions and be confident to take the game on. A player can follow a gameplan to a tee but he needs to be more daring at times.

Brisbane is clearly not the power it was in the early 2000s but it does not mean that the current list should be a bunch of quitters or lack determination.

These players are playing at the elite level and they should have an inferiority complex regardless of who they play against. If they are playing with fear and they aren’t willing to make changes, these players should play at a lower level.

Leppitsch’s Brisbane side lacks structure and he has too many players out of place. Hardly anyone players one-on-one footy at the AFL level these days so people should not expect to see a team with six defenders, three midfielders, three on-ballers and six forwards. Players should still play in roles that suit their characteristics though.

Teams need to look at the style of football or the philosophy that they want to implement. Brisbane lacks a clear gameplan or style. What the Lions usually do is move the ball slowly and they chip the football along the wings. If not, the Lions constantly handball through the midfield before turning the ball over.

The Lions need to be quicker in their decision making or be more instinctive. Instead of constantly moving the ball down the wings lethargically, they need to move the ball quickly down the corridor and rely on kicking as opposed to handballing.

Traditionally teams would kick the ball long into a contest and perhaps that won’t work too often in the modern game but it is still a useful concept. Even if a player can’t kick to a contest, he should kick it into a space in which a teammate can run into.

Under Leppitsch, there have been very little signs of improvement. Regardless of what Brisbane does in the trade period and in pre-season, “Leppa” doesn’t look like the man to take the Lions forward. Having better players won’t be enough to make him a successful coach.

He needs to resign or the board need to give him the sack.

Thursday, 11 June 2015

Top 10 AFL Footballers That Vito Doria Has Seen

Chris Judd announced his retirement on Tuesday and media and fans alike were quick to find a place where he ranks among the best footballers of his era.

I have decided to do a Top 10 list of the best AFL footballers that I have seen. Although I started watching football in 1993, I really started watching the game week-in, week-out in 1999 so I will only include players from that year until today.

Due to the criteria, players like Gary Ablett Snr, Jason Dunstall, Greg Williams and Tony Lockett miss out but due to the size of the list, eligible players such as Jonathan Brown, Anthony Koutoufides, Jimmy Bartel, Dane Swan and Matthew Pavlich unfortunately miss out.

This list will raise eyebrows but enjoy reading.

10. Steve Johnson – Geelong (2002-present)

Games: 243
Goals: 435
Honours: AFL premiership (2007, 2009 and 2011), Norm Smith Medal (2007), Geelong leading goalkicker (2008 and 2010), All-Australian (2007-08 and 2010)

“Stevie J” has been the player that provides some X-factor in the Geelong forward line. Mark “Bomber” Thompson had Cameron Mooney and Brad Ottens as marking targets and Paul Chapman was a tough small, forward. Johnson was and still is the mercurial goalkicker who can make the hard things look easy.

9. James Hird – Essendon (1992-2007)

Games: 253
Goals: 343
Honours: AFL premiership (1993 and 2000), Brownlow Medal (1996), Norm Smith Medal (2000), W.S. Crichton Medal (1994-96, 2003 and 2007), Anzac Day Medal (2000, 2003-04), All-Australian (1995-96, 2000-01, 2003)

“Hirdy” was a man for the big occasion as his Anzac Day Medals and Norm Smith Medal illustrate. The heart and soul of Essendon in the 1990s and 2000s, he was a superb half-forward flanker before finding more time in the midfield. Injuries possibly halted him back from being even more devastating.

8. Chris Judd – West Coast and Carlton (2002-15)

Games: 279 (134 with West Coast, 145 with Carlton)
Goals: 228 (138 with West Coast, 90 with Carlton)
Honours: AFL premiership (2006), Brownlow Medal (2004 and 2010), Norm Smith Medal (2005), All-Australian (2004, 2006, 2008-11), John Worsfold Medal (2004 and 2006), John Nicholls Medal (2008-10), Ross Glendinning Medal (2005 (twice), 2006)

“Juddy” was a ball magnet and a superb athlete. He had great strength, stamina and pace. Although he is highly-regarded by football fans and media, I found his style to be rather plain. He used his physical attributes to great effect, especially with his ability to weave through packs but there were players even in his era who were either tougher, more graceful or had more flair.

7. Adam Goodes – Sydney (1999-present)

Games: 359
Goals: 447
Honours: AFL premiership (2005 and 2012), Brownlow Medal (2003, 2006), AFL Rising star (1999), Bob Skilton Medal (2003, 2006 and 2011), All-Australian (2003, 2006, 2009, 2011), Sydney leading goalkicker (2009-11)

Goodes has been a graceful mover around the ground, especially for someone of his height. A player who is comfortable as an on-baller and in the forward 50, his athleticism and agility have made Goodes a tough player to stop in full flight.

6. Luke Hodge - Hawthorn

Games: 257
Goals: 173
Honours: AFL premiership (2008 and 2013-14), Norm Smith Medal (2008 and 2014), All-Australian (2005, 2008 and 2010), Peter Crimmins Medal (2005 and 2010)

A tenacious player but one with great skill and versatility, Hodge is a player that feels comfortable wherever he plays on the field. “Hodgey” can play as a ‘sweeper’ in defence, become a ball magnet in midfield as well as do the gritty stuff, and he can also chip-in with his share of goals.

5. Robert Harvey – St Kilda (1988-2008)

Games: 383
Goals: 215
Honours: Brownlow Medal (1997-98), Trevor Barker Award (1992, 1994, 1997-98), All-Australian (1992, 1994-99, 2003)

These days, people are in awe of Gary Ablett Jnr getting more than 40 disposals a game. The game has changed in the millennium but in the 1990s, it was remarkable for someone to regularly get over 30 disposals a game. Robert Harvey used to do that. He was a ball magnet and he could run all day. Despite injuries, he still managed to play in the VFL/AFL for over 20 years.

4. Michael Voss – Brisbane Lions (1992-2006)

Games: 289
Goals: 245
Honours: AFL premiership (2001-03), Brownlow Medal (1996), All-Australian (1996, 1999, 2001-03), Brisbane Best and Fairest (1995-96, 2000-01, 2003)

“Vossy” was tough, courageous and skilful. The captain of Brisbane during the Lions three-peat, he was a great leader and he was an outstanding performer in a midfield blessed with talent.

3. Jason Akermanis – Brisbane Lions and Western Bulldogs (1995-2010)

Games: 325 (248 with Brisbane, 77 with the Western Bulldogs)
Goals: 421 (307 with Brisbane, 114 with the Western Bulldogs)
Honours: AFL premiership (2001-03), Brownlow Medal (2001), Merrett-Murray Medal (1999 and 2005), All-Australian (1999, 2001-02, 2004), Brisbane leading goalkicker (2004), Western Bulldogs leading goalkicker (2009)

“Aker” was known for his colourful personality but he was a phenomenal footballer. He had big mouth but his talent was even bigger. A mercurial player, he did things most other players could dream of. Great with both feet, Akermanis could snap goals from anywhere and he could score from the most impossible of angles.

2. Wayne Carey – North Melbourne and Adelaide (1989-2004)

Games: 272 (244 with North Melbourne, 28 with Adelaide)
Goals: 727 (671 with North Melbourne, 67 with Adelaide)
Honours: AFL premiership (1996 and 1999), All-Australian (1993-96, 1998-2000), Syd Barker Medal (1992-93, 1996 and 1998), North Melbourne leading goalkicker (1995-96, 1998-2000)

Although he wasn’t as good as he was in the new millennium as he was in the 1990s, he was a genuine match-winner. North Melbourne had stars in its team but Carey was head and shoulders above the rest. He made marking and kicking goals look so easy even if he had defenders on him.

1. Gary Ablett Jnr – Geelong and Gold Coast (2002-present)

Games: 270 (192 with Geelong, 78 with Gold Coast)
Goals: 361 (262 with Geelong, 99 with Gold Coast)
Honours: AFL premiership (2007 and 2009), Brownlow Medal (2009 and 2013), All-Australian (2007-14), Geelong leading goalkicker (2006), Carji Greeves Medal (2007 and 2009), Gold Coast Club Champion Award (2011-13), Gold Coast leading goalscorer (2012 and 2013)

If this was a debate about who was the better Ablett, Gary Snr would get my vote. Gary Jnr is still an amazing player though and he has played well in a great team like Geelong and in a struggling team like Gold Coast. A great player at ground level, he can rack up at least 40 possessions in game effortlessly.